WalletPrep

What is an ETF, and how does it work?

An ETF is a fund that trades like a stock, so one purchase can buy a slice of hundreds of companies.

Investing6 min readUpdated

Dana has $1,000 and an ETF at $80.

New to this?

A fund pools money from many people to buy many investments at once. An ETF, short for exchange-traded fund, is a fund whose shares trade on a stock exchange all day, like a company's stock. You buy it in a brokerage account or IRA. One share can hold a sliver of hundreds of stocks or bonds.

Myth

ETFs are a fancy trader thing. Regular people should stay away.

Truth

A plain index ETF is one of the simplest things you can own. Dana's first $1,000 buys 12 shares of a broad fund that charges 0.03% a year, about 29 cents on $960.

Worth memorizing

  1. 1

    An ETF is a fund trading like a stock.

    You buy and sell shares during the day at the market price, through a brokerage account or an IRA.

  2. 2

    What it holds matters more than the label.

    A broad index ETF spreads your money widely. A narrow theme ETF or a 2x fund can be far riskier.

  3. 3

    You pay a yearly fee plus a small spread.

    The expense ratio comes out every year. The bid-ask spread is a small hidden cost each time you trade.

James's take

Here's what I'd do: pick one broad, low-cost index ETF, buy it on a schedule and leave it alone. I'd skip anything with 2x, 3x, inverse or a hot theme in the name. The ETF wrapper is fine. What's inside it is what matters.

Do this today

Look up one broad index ETF available in your IRA or brokerage account. Write down its expense ratio, its number of holdings and its top 10 holdings. If it charges more than about 0.20% for a broad fund, compare it with one or two others.

Practice

1 of 3

What is the main way an ETF differs from a mutual fund?

2 of 3

An ETF trades at $50 a share. How many whole shares does $430 buy?

3 of 3

Which ETF is most likely to drift away from its index over many months?

Tips

Read the fund's holdings first

The fund's website lists what it owns. A broad fund holds hundreds or thousands of companies. If the top 10 holdings are most of the fund, it is narrow.

Use limit orders for big buys

A limit order sets the most you will pay per share. It keeps you from paying far more than the fund is worth in a fast market.

Trade when the market is open

Prices and spreads can jump right at the open and close. Placing orders mid-day usually gets a price close to what the fund's holdings are worth.

Skip 2x, 3x and inverse funds

These reset every day and can lose money over months even when the index ends up flat. The SEC warns that buy-and-hold investors should generally avoid them.

A worked example: Dana's first $1,000 ETF purchase

Dana, 26, opened a Roth IRA and moved in $1,000. She picks a broad US stock index ETF trading at $80 a share, with a 0.03% expense ratio. Her brokerage sells whole shares only.

  1. $1,000 ÷ $80 = 12.5, so whole shares mean 12 shares. 12 × $80 = $960, leaving $1,000 − $960 = $40 in cash for next month's purchase.
  2. The yearly fee is $960 × 0.03% = about $0.29. At a 1% fee, the same holding would cost $9.60 a year.
  3. With a 4-cent spread, buying and later selling 12 shares costs about 12 × $0.04 = $0.48 in total. Holding for years keeps that cost tiny.
The math
  1. Cash in the account+$1,000
  2. 12 shares at $80−$960
  3. Left in cash=$40
  4. Invested in the ETF$960
  5. Yearly fee at 0.03%$0.29
  6. Spread cost, 12 shares$0.48
Finish the lessonDo the practice above, or mark it done if you already know this.
Expense ratiosThe quiet yearly fee that compounds against you.Next: Expense ratios →

Try your numbers

Common mistakes

Treating every ETF as safe

ETF only describes how the fund trades. A broad index ETF and a 3x single-industry fund share the label but carry very different risk. Read what the fund holds.

Trading it like a game

Because ETFs trade all day, it is easy to buy and sell on every headline. Each trade costs a spread and can trigger taxes in a regular account. A schedule beats reacting.

Owning five funds that hold the same thing

Several large-company US ETFs can own mostly the same stocks. You pay several fees and get little extra spread. Compare the top holdings before adding another fund.

Going deeper

An ETF (exchange-traded fund) is a basket of many investments that you buy and sell like a single stock, at a price that changes during the trading day. Many ETFs are low-cost index funds, so one share can spread your money across hundreds or thousands of companies.

It is a fund with a stock-like price

Like a mutual fund, an ETF pools money and owns many investments, and each share is a small slice of the whole. Unlike a mutual fund, you buy its shares on a stock exchange at the market price during the day.

Most beginner ETFs are index funds

An index ETF copies a list, such as the whole US stock market or a broad bond index. Because no one is picking stocks, the yearly fee can be very low. Some ETFs are actively managed and cost more.

Costs come in three pieces

The expense ratio is the yearly fee. The bid-ask spread is the small gap between the buying and selling price. Some brokerages also charge a trade commission, though many charge none for ETFs.

Some ETFs are built for traders

Funds that try to double, triple or reverse a market's daily move work on a one-day basis. Over longer periods their results can drift far from what the name suggests.

What you own when you buy an ETF

When you buy one share of an ETF, you own a tiny piece of everything in the fund. If the fund holds 3,000 companies, your share holds a sliver of all 3,000. When those companies pay dividends, the fund passes them on to you, usually every quarter.

The fund's value, called its net asset value or NAV, is what all its holdings are worth divided by the number of shares. The fund has to calculate it every business day. ETFs must register with the SEC and publish what they own, so you can always check what is inside.

How the price works during the day

ETF shares trade between investors on an exchange, so the price moves all day with supply and demand. The market price usually stays very close to the NAV. Large trading firms can swap baskets of stocks for ETF shares and back, and they profit from closing any gap, which pulls the price back in line.

Sometimes the price runs a little above the NAV (a premium) or below it (a discount). For a large, popular fund, the gap is usually tiny. For a small or thinly traded fund, it can be bigger, especially in a fast market. The fund's website shows its past premiums and discounts.

ETF or mutual fund

Both are ways to own a basket of investments, and many index funds come in both versions. A mutual fund trades once a day, after the market closes, at the NAV. You can usually buy it in exact dollar amounts, such as $250, though some have a minimum first purchase.

An ETF trades all day at the market price. You buy shares, so a $96 share price means $96 per share, unless your brokerage offers fractional shares. ETFs are often a bit more tax-efficient in a regular taxable account because of how they handle redemptions, so they tend to pass along fewer capital gains. Inside a 401(k) or IRA, that tax difference does not matter.

What an ETF costs you

The expense ratio is a yearly percentage of what you hold. At 0.03%, you pay $3 a year for every $10,000. You never see a bill. The fund takes it out of its assets bit by bit, which lowers your return slightly.

The bid-ask spread is the other cost. The bid is the most a buyer will pay right now and the ask is the least a seller will take. If a share is quoted at $79.98 and $80.02, the spread is 4 cents. You pay a little of that each time you buy or sell. Busy, large funds tend to have very small spreads. Trading rarely keeps this cost small.

ETFs to be careful with

Funds with 2x, 3x, ultra or inverse in the name use derivatives or borrowed money to multiply or flip a market's daily move. Because they reset every day, a few up and down days can leave them well behind the index they follow. The SEC says they can expose investors to sudden, large losses over periods longer than a day.

Narrow theme funds are a quieter risk. A fund that holds 40 companies in one hot industry is not spread out. Check the number of holdings and the top 10 before you buy.

How to buy your first ETF

Open an IRA or a brokerage account, move money in from your bank, and search for the fund by its ticker, the short code it trades under. Check the expense ratio and holdings, then place an order. A market order buys right away at the current price. A limit order lets you set the highest price you will pay.

After that, keep buying on a schedule and leave it alone. Easy trading is handy, but frequent trading tends to cost money.

Questions people ask

Are ETFs good for beginners?

A broad, low-cost index ETF can be a simple first investment for money you won't need for at least 5 years. The risk comes from what the fund holds, so start with a fund that owns a whole market, not a slice of one.

Can you lose money in an ETF?

Yes. An ETF is worth what its holdings are worth, so a stock ETF falls when stocks fall. Stock prices can drop 20% or more within months. ETFs are not insured by the FDIC.

Do ETFs pay dividends?

Most stock and bond ETFs pass along the dividends and interest their holdings pay, often every quarter or every month. You can usually set your account to reinvest them automatically into more shares.

Is an ETF the same as an index fund?

Not always. An index fund is any fund that copies an index, and it can be an ETF or a mutual fund. Many ETFs are index funds, but some are actively managed or follow complex strategies.

Printable worksheet with answer key, free for classrooms. Lesson plan for this unit.

Sources

Terms on this page

Related lessons