WalletPrep

How do CDs work, and are they worth it?

A CD locks a fixed rate for a set term. Use it only for money you won't need before that date.

Saving5 min readUpdated

Leah locks $5,000 for 5 years at 4.00%.

New to this?

A certificate of deposit, or CD, is a savings deposit with a deal attached. You agree to leave a set amount at a bank or credit union for a set time, called the term. In return, the rate stays the same the whole time. Take the money out early and you usually pay a penalty.

Myth

A CD is a safe place for my emergency fund because it pays more.

Truth

It's insured, but it isn't reachable without a cost. In the example, cashing out a 5-year CD after 6 months leaves Leah with $4,899 of her $5,000.

Worth memorizing

  1. 1

    A CD trades access for a locked rate.

    The rate can't drop during the term. In return, taking money out early usually costs a penalty set by the bank.

  2. 2

    The penalty can be bigger than your interest.

    Leah's 5-year CD earned $99 in 6 months, but the 12-month penalty was about $200. She got back $4,899.

  3. 3

    Match the term to the date you need it.

    Money for a goal in 12 months fits a 12-month CD. If the date is fuzzy, keep the money in savings instead.

James's take

Here's what I'd do. Keep the emergency fund in savings, and use CDs only for money with a date on it, like a car purchase in 12 months. Pick a term that ends just before that date, and read the penalty line before you sign.

Do this today

Write down any savings goal with a firm date in the next 6 to 24 months. Then look up the APY and early withdrawal penalty for a CD at your bank and one online bank that matures just before that date.

Practice

1 of 3

You have $8,000 and you're sure you'll need it for tuition in 12 months. Which fits best?

2 of 3

A $10,000 CD has a 3.00% APY and a penalty of 6 months of interest. About how big is the penalty?

3 of 3

Your CD matured yesterday and renews automatically. What can you usually do now without a penalty?

Tips

Find the penalty before opening

Banks set their own early withdrawal penalties. A common form is a number of months of interest, and longer terms often charge more. It is listed in the account disclosure.

Mark the maturity date

Many CDs renew on their own for another term. Put the maturity date in your calendar so you can move the money during the grace period if you want to.

Compare APY, not the rate

APY (annual percentage yield) includes compounding, so it is the fair number to compare across banks, credit unions and terms.

Ladder bigger amounts

Split a large sum across CDs that end at different times, such as 6, 12 and 18 months. Part of the money comes free every few months.

A worked example: breaking a 5-year CD early

Leah puts $5,000 in a 5-year CD at a 4.00% APY (an example rate). The penalty is 12 months of interest. After 6 months, her car needs a $4,500 repair.

  1. Six months at a 4.00% APY earns $5,000 × (1.04 to the power of 0.5 − 1) = about $99.
  2. A year of interest is $5,000 × 4.00% = $200, so the penalty is about $200. $5,099 − $200 = $4,899, which is $101 less than she put in.
  3. Had she kept it 5 years, it would grow to $5,000 × 1.04 × 1.04 × 1.04 × 1.04 × 1.04 = about $6,083. The lock only pays if you keep it.
The math
  1. Deposit$5,000
  2. Interest earned in 6 months+$99
  3. CD value at 6 months=$5,099
  4. Penalty, 12 months of interest−$200
  5. Leah gets back=$4,899
  6. If kept the full 5 years$6,083
Finish the lessonDo the practice above, or mark it done if you already know this.
Money market accountsInsured savings with checks, minimums and a variable rate.Next: Money market accounts →

Try your numbers

Common mistakes

Locking up money you might need

If there is a real chance you'll need the cash before maturity, the penalty risk outweighs the extra rate. Keep that money in insured savings.

Letting it renew without looking

An automatic renewal can lock you into a new term at a lower rate. Use the grace period to compare rates and move the money if a better option exists.

Going over the insurance limit

Your CDs, savings and checking at one bank all count toward the same $250,000 limit per ownership category. Spread larger sums across banks or check your coverage on the FDIC site.

Going deeper

A CD (certificate of deposit) pays a fixed rate if you leave your money at the bank for a set term, from a few months to 5 years. It is worth it for money with a known date, and a poor fit for anything you might need early, because the penalty can eat your interest and even some of your deposit.

The rate is fixed for the term

Most CDs pay one rate from the day you open them to the day they mature (reach the end of the term). Savings rates can fall at any time, so a CD protects you from a rate cut.

Insured like savings

CDs at FDIC-insured banks and NCUA-insured credit unions are covered up to $250,000 per depositor, per institution, per ownership category, together with your other deposits there.

Early withdrawal costs money

Each bank sets its own penalty, often a few months to a year of interest. If you cash out early, the penalty can be larger than the interest earned so far, which cuts into your deposit.

Interest is taxable each year

CD interest counts as income on your federal return, and usually your state return, for the year it is credited, even if you leave it in the CD. Banks send a Form 1099-INT when interest is $10 or more.

How a CD works, step by step

You pick a term, such as 6 months, 1 year or 5 years, and deposit a lump sum. The bank tells you the rate and APY up front, along with the maturity date and the penalty for early withdrawal. Federal Truth in Savings rules require banks to give you those terms in writing.

Interest is added on a schedule, often monthly or quarterly. At the end of the term you can withdraw the money and interest, move it, or let it roll into a new CD. Most CDs add money only once, at the start.

When a CD is worth it

A CD makes sense when you know the date you'll need the money and you won't touch it before then. A car purchase next summer, a tuition bill in 18 months or a planned move are good examples. You get a rate that can't be cut, and the money is out of sight.

It also helps when rates look likely to fall. A savings account at 4.00% today might pay 3.25% next year. A CD keeps its rate until it matures. When rates are rising, a short term keeps you from being stuck at a low rate for years.

When a CD is a bad idea

Skip CDs for your emergency fund and for any money without a firm date. The extra rate over a good high-yield savings account is often small. One early withdrawal can wipe it out.

Also skip them for long-term goals like retirement. Over 20 or 30 years, a fixed rate on cash usually struggles to stay ahead of inflation. That money belongs in a retirement account invested for growth, which carries more short-term risk.

What happens when your CD matures

Many CDs renew on their own into a new CD of the same length, at whatever rate the bank is paying that day. For terms longer than a month, the bank must send you a notice before the CD renews. That notice comes at least 30 days before maturity, or at least 20 days before the grace period ends if the grace period is 5 days or longer.

The grace period is a short window, often 7 to 10 days, when you can take the money out with no penalty. If you miss it, the money is locked again for a full new term. Set a reminder a week before maturity.

Building a CD ladder

A CD ladder spreads one large sum across several CDs that mature at different times. Say you have $9,000 for costs over the next 18 months. You could put $3,000 each into 6-month, 12-month and 18-month CDs. Every 6 months, one CD matures and the cash is there if you need it.

If you don't need it, you can roll it into a new CD at the top of the ladder. A ladder gives you some of the rate of longer CDs with more frequent access.

Other kinds of CDs

A no-penalty CD lets you withdraw early without a fee, usually after the first few days, and often pays a little less. A brokered CD is sold through a brokerage firm. You usually can't break it early at the bank; you sell it to another buyer at the market price, which can be lower than you paid. A callable CD lets the bank end it early, often when rates fall.

Read the disclosure for any CD that isn't a plain bank CD. Check who holds it, whether it is insured and how you get your money out before maturity.

Questions people ask

Can you lose money in a CD?

Not from the bank failing, as long as your deposits there stay within the insurance limit. You can get back less than you put in if you withdraw early and the penalty is larger than the interest earned so far.

Is a 1-year or 5-year CD better?

Pick the term by when you'll need the money, not by the rate alone. A longer CD may pay more, but breaking it early costs more too. If you're unsure, a shorter term or a ladder keeps more options open.

How much does a $10,000 CD earn in a year?

Multiply by the APY. At an example 4.00% APY, $10,000 earns $10,000 × 4.00% = $400 over 12 months. At 3.00%, it earns $300. Rates change often, so check the current APY at a few insured banks and credit unions.

Do I pay tax on CD interest if I don't withdraw it?

Yes. CD interest is generally taxable in the year it is credited to your account, even if it stays in the CD. Your bank reports it on Form 1099-INT. Check IRS guidance for your situation.

Printable worksheet with answer key, free for classrooms. Lesson plan for this unit.

Sources

Terms on this page

Related lessons