WalletPrep

Is a credit union better than a bank?

Both are insured and offer the same basics. Credit unions often charge less on loans, while banks are easier to join.

Money basics4 min readUpdated

$20,000 car loan at the bank: $4,046 interest.

New to this?

A credit union is like a bank owned by the people who use it. Members share something in common, like an employer, a town or a school, and profits go back to them as lower fees and better rates. A bank is a business owned by shareholders. Both hold your money, make loans and are insured by the government.

Read first

Myth

My money isn't as safe at a credit union as it is at a bank.

Truth

Federally insured credit unions are covered by the NCUA up to $250,000, the same as the FDIC limit for banks, and both are backed by the full faith and credit of the United States.

Worth memorizing

  1. 1

    Credit unions are owned by their members.

    Profits go back to members as lower fees, lower loan rates and higher savings rates, instead of to shareholders.

  2. 2

    Both are insured up to the same limit.

    The FDIC covers banks and the NCUA covers federally insured credit unions, each up to $250,000 per owner, per institution, per category.

  3. 3

    Credit unions require membership.

    You join through a shared link, like where you live, work or study, or a family member who belongs.

James's take

I'd get a loan quote from a credit union before signing any car loan. It takes one phone call, and on a typical loan even 1 point of APR can save hundreds of dollars. For everyday checking, pick whichever has no monthly fee and ATMs near you.

Do this today

Search the NCUA's credit union locator for credit unions near your home or work, and read the membership rules for two of them. Note their checking fees and current car loan APR.

Practice

1 of 3

Who owns a credit union?

2 of 3

A $10,000 loan costs $1,700 in total interest at one lender and $1,420 at another. How much does the cheaper one save?

3 of 3

How does deposit insurance at a federally insured credit union compare with a bank?

Tips

Get a credit union loan quote

Before you finance a car or take a personal loan, ask a credit union for its APR. Use it to compare, or to push a dealer or bank lower.

Check you can join

Look at the credit union's field of membership. Many accept anyone who lives or works in an area, or who joins a partner group.

Ask about ATMs and branches

Some credit unions belong to shared branch and ATM networks. Ask how many free ATMs are near your home and work before you switch.

Look for the insurance sign

Confirm a bank is FDIC insured or a credit union is NCUA insured. Look for the sign at the branch or on the website.

A worked example: the same car loan at a bank and a credit union

Marcus, a warehouse supervisor, is borrowing $20,000 for 60 months. His bank offers 7.5% APR. A credit union he can join offers 6.5%. These are example rates.

  1. Using the standard loan payment formula, $20,000 over 60 months costs about $401 a month at 7.5% and $391 at 6.5%.
  2. Total interest is about $4,046 at the bank and $3,479 at the credit union. $4,046 − $3,479 = $567 saved.
  3. Marcus joins the credit union with a small deposit and takes its loan. He keeps his bank checking account for its ATMs.
The math
  1. Payment at 7.5% APR$401
  2. Payment at 6.5% APR$391
  3. Total interest at the bank$4,046
  4. Total interest at the credit union−$3,479
  5. Saved over the loan=$567
Finish the lessonDo the practice above, or mark it done if you already know this.
How interest worksThe price of money, earned or paid.Next: How interest works →

Try your numbers

Common mistakes

Assuming one is always cheaper

Credit unions often win on loans, but not every time. Ask both for the APR on the same loan amount and term, then pick the lower one.

Skipping the membership check

You can't use a credit union's rate until you can join. Read its eligibility rules first, so you don't count on a loan you can't get.

Forgetting about ATM access

A great rate loses its shine if every cash withdrawal costs $3 or more in out-of-network fees. Check where the free ATMs are.

Going deeper

A credit union is a not-for-profit owned by its members, and a bank is usually a for-profit company owned by shareholders. Both offer checking, savings and loans, both are federally insured up to $250,000, and credit unions often charge less on loans and fees, so compare actual offers before you choose.

The main difference is who owns it

Credit unions are not-for-profit cooperatives owned by members, with a volunteer board the members elect. Banks are usually for-profit companies run for their shareholders.

Your deposits are equally protected

Bank deposits are covered by the FDIC up to $250,000, and credit union deposits by the NCUA's Share Insurance Fund up to $250,000, per owner, per institution, per ownership category.

Credit unions often price loans lower

Because profits return to members, credit unions often offer lower loan rates, lower fees and higher savings rates. It varies a lot, so compare the actual APR and APY you are offered.

Banks can be easier to join and use

Anyone can open a bank account, and large banks and online banks may offer more ATMs, branches or app features. Small credit unions may have fewer locations.

How a credit union works

When you join a credit union, you open a savings account, often called a share account, and become a part owner. You get a vote on the board of directors, no matter how much money you have there. The credit union lends members' deposits to other members, and any profit goes back to members.

To join, you need to fit its field of membership. That might be an employer, a school, a military branch, a church or a geographic area. Many credit unions also let family members join, and some let anyone in who first joins a partner group. Most ask for a small opening deposit.

How a bank works

A bank is a business that takes deposits and makes loans to earn a profit for its owners. Anyone who meets its account rules can open an account. Banks range from small community banks to national banks with branches in many states, plus online banks with no branches at all.

Large banks tend to have more branches and ATMs, longer hours and more features in their apps. Online banks often pay higher savings rates because they have no branches to run. Fees vary widely, so read the fee schedule for the account you want.

Rates and fees

The NCUA says credit unions return their profits to members as reduced fees, higher savings rates and lower loan rates. That is a tendency, not a promise. An online bank may pay more on savings than a local credit union, and a bank may beat a credit union on a mortgage.

The fair test is the actual offer. For a loan, compare the APR, which includes the interest rate and some fees. For savings, compare the APY. For checking, look at the monthly fee, the minimum balance and the overdraft fee.

Safety and insurance

Banks are insured by the FDIC. Federal credit unions and the large majority of state-chartered credit unions are insured by the NCUA. Both cover $250,000 per owner, per institution, per ownership category, and both are backed by the full faith and credit of the United States.

A few state-chartered credit unions use private insurance instead. Look for the NCUA sign at the branch or on the website, or use the NCUA's credit union locator, before you deposit.

Using both

You don't have to choose just one. Many people keep checking at a bank with lots of ATMs, savings at an online bank with a high APY, and use a credit union for car loans. Insurance limits apply per institution, so spreading money across several also spreads the coverage.

Questions people ask

Can anyone join a credit union?

Not every credit union, but most people can find one to join. Each has a field of membership based on things like where you live, work, worship or study, or a family member who belongs. Some open membership to anyone who joins a partner group.

What are the downsides of a credit union?

You have to qualify for membership, some have fewer branches and ATMs, and app features can be more basic. Rates also vary, so a credit union is not always the cheapest option for every product.

Is it better to get a car loan from a credit union or a bank?

Get quotes from both, plus the dealer, for the same amount and term, and compare the APR. Credit unions often come in lower on car loans, and a written quote gives you something to negotiate with.

Can I have accounts at both a bank and a credit union?

Yes. There is no limit on how many institutions you use. Many people keep checking at one place, savings at another and loans at a credit union, and each institution's insurance coverage is separate.

Printable worksheet with answer key, free for classrooms. Lesson plan for this unit.

Sources

Terms on this page

Related lessons